One is exactly enough
14 Mar 2012
I am wearing a sign. It floats above my head. Like a speech bubble. It reads:
I have only one child, please ask me when I am having another one.
Just this morning on the way into the office, I was grilled about my failure to produce more offspring. It is a regular topic of conversation. I get asked about it almost every day. Even people who don’t know me well seem very keen to talk about my reproductive potential. So common is this line of inquiry that I have toyed with getting t-shirts printed. I thought about something similar to the ‘Don’t ask me about my PhD’ shirts that used to be popular at ANU. Perhaps ‘Don’t ask about the unborn’ or maybe ‘Yes, I only have one child’. Or even ‘Don’t you know I’m 39?’ Mind you, that probably wouldn’t be enough to put them off.
I remember having this conversation over and over immediately after Benedict was born. I couldn’t quite believe that having only just had my first child that people were talking about the next one! I’d only just got him home and had started the whole shocking adjustment period, when people started talking about second children. The medicos, the midwives, the GP, they were all in on it. At the time, it felt like a bit of conspiracy. You’ll be back, said the midwife confidently. I just had a baby; I thought to myself, how can you be talking about having more babies? I just had one! (Might have a lie down now thank you, instead of talking about having more children, goodbye.)
These questions have continued intermittently over the past two years, especially after the first of the mothers’ group started to announce their second pregnancies. Some of those brave souls went really early, some of them accidentally, or perhaps more kindly, in a time frame that was perhaps not entirely of their choosing. I was slightly alarmed by their embrace of the idea of two children in nappies. Eeek!
Recently, the questioning about a sibling for Benedict has hit fever pitch. Everywhere I turn at the moment, women I know who had their first child around the summer of 2009/10, at the same time as I had Benedict, are pregnant or have had their second children. My Facebook page is like a congratulatory wall of motherhood glory, full of pictures of newborns and announcements. It seems weekly at present, another email comes full of expectation and joy. This is to be expected, of course, a nice two-ish year gap between children is nice, sensible and predictable. Happens all the time.
This festival of motherhood continues unabated around me. I have been reading a lot of blog posts about stopping after three children, and the excitement of seeing how differently they turn out. These paeans of love for children, in the plural, are full of the conviction that there is immense pleasure in a brood of children. Women with grown up children talk to me about when they had their second, or their third child, with a tone that indicates ‘you’ll see, you won’t be able to help yourself’. People ask me about having another or even the more presumptuous, when I am having another one. For a while at work, it was rumoured I was pregnant already. But to the deep disappointment of the observers, I was just getting fat.
Two weeks ago, I went to visit one of these delightful new little people, born serendipitously on my birthday. I ended up in a conversation with the obstetrician about having more babies. It is his business, of course, and so he was keen, but the tone of this conversation was, as always, you’ll be back, you will change your mind, you’ll see. Despite the fact that I was holding a tiny three-day old baby at the time, it was very easy for me to just say; no I didn’t want any more children. Easy. Just like that. He didn’t believe me. You’ll be back, he kept saying.
I’ve started to reply with a flat no! No, I won’t be having any more! These conversations are often so bizarre, I wonder if there is anything coming out of my mouth at all. Am I still speaking? Are you people listening to me? I am not having any more children. You’ll change your mind, you’ll see, they say. Er, no, I won’t, I reply. But thank you, dear person, for your interest in the none of your business topic of my nascent children. Even before I went through 38 hours of labour to bring Benedict into the world, I knew I would only have one. I knew that this singleton birth would be the only one. An only child.
Why then? Why am I so sure?
I have one lovely child and he is fantastic. I have known for a long, long time, that if I did have any children at all, I would only have one. In fact, until 2009 there was still a big question over whether or not I would have any at all. I have always wanted to just have one. I am glad that I had one, but one is exactly enough. I have no desire to have any more. And whether or not you believe it, that’s just how it is. I have one child and that is as many as I want to have and as many as I am going to have.
One is exactly enough.
Renee | About a Bugg
Nov 01, 2012 @ 18:44:57
Oh I just discovered your blog and read this post – and coincidentally I wrote on the exact same topic this week.
My only daughter is now almost 8 and people still ask. Regularly.
Ugh.
beth
Jun 12, 2012 @ 01:14:43
Refreshing. So many layers to get through about the stigma of ‘just one’ and so lovely you are ‘at one’ with it. Enjoy every minute of it. I would rather be an awesome Mum to one child than an exhausted rubbish Mum to more. Instead of more children, I am going to get a couple of cats and write a few novels….
Yvette Vignando
Mar 26, 2012 @ 20:27:56
There have been similar pieces around about being asked “So do you have children?” ” So, when are you having your next child?” “Are you trying for a boy now?” – on and on it goes.
But none so eloquent as yours to express the presumptuousness of all this.
One is perfect, as is three or eight.
Stella Orbit
Mar 26, 2012 @ 21:37:16
Thank for your beautiful comment. I loved writing this.
The comments have been wonderful xo
Karen
Mar 21, 2012 @ 22:36:34
I love the way this whirled and whirled and whirled, and as it moved the circle got tighter and tighter until you reached your perfect conclusion. One is exactly enough. Love it. :)
Stella Orbit
Mar 26, 2012 @ 21:36:32
Thank you. It was a joy to write, I really had to express these thoughts xo
Kylie L
Mar 15, 2012 @ 20:43:43
I knew when I was pregnant with Cam that that was it – I was done with two. Luckily my husband felt the same, and even more luckily – for the general public, not me – she was a girl. I couldn’t have cared less, but 99% of people spying my pregnant belly and learning I already had a son asked me if I was “trying for a girl this time” (here’s a tip: if my gut is sticking in your face it’s too late to try for anything.)
People are idiots. My sister is 42, separated and has the one perfect daughter. She is STILL frequently asked when she is going to give Emily a “playmate”. I believe she is currently answering “When I get the time to make the trip to the kennels.”
Great blog!
Stella Orbit
Mar 15, 2012 @ 21:02:37
The trying part was already over by then! Hilarious.
Another fantastic response to add to my growing collection.
Thanks xo
Robert Gotts
Mar 15, 2012 @ 20:16:42
Dear Louise
I guess that your post answers the question of whether we should have another baby to keep Benedict company.
Much Love
Robert
Twitchy
Mar 15, 2012 @ 15:48:05
People will always comment; people will always make assumptions. When my boy was 4, 5 and just-turned-six people would say to me “oh, it’s mean/unfair to have an only child”. One, had he been an only child, it’s none of their business, and two, who were they to label my boy an only child?! His sister arrived the following year, long awaited and very much completing our family. And two is perfect. For ME. xxx
Stella Orbit
Mar 15, 2012 @ 20:57:17
Perfect, for you. That’s just it isn’t it? It is such a personal matter.
It is neither mean or unfair, it just is.
Lovely story, thank you xo
Nathalie Brown
Mar 15, 2012 @ 14:24:13
Hi Louise, even though I work with behaviour 24/7 it never ceases to amaze me what people just blurt out. I was told we couldn’t have kids, I would need IVF, then by a freak of nature I became pregnant with my daughter. They said she was a miracle there would be no more. Yet everyone would say she needs a brother or a sister, I’d say I can’t have anymore, to more comments or that’s a shame. Why was it shame? I was ecstatic I had a daughter. Nine years later a miracle son was born, there is a nine year gap and now I get questions like ‘oh is the big one adopted, are they from the same dad?’ You can never win. Really enjoyed reading your post, enjoy your gorgeous son Nx
Stella Orbit
Mar 15, 2012 @ 20:53:56
Nice to know that this even happens to the professionals.
So pleased that you were lucky twice, amazing.
Thank you for your lovely comment xo
Ruth Bruten
Mar 15, 2012 @ 14:08:14
I LOVE this post…..I LOVE it because I love your writing & that I can hear your voice telling me these words.
But I am so sad that ANY of us have to write this stuff down.
Why oh why do we have to justify our decisions to ANYONE except ourselves?
Why oh why do people not listen?
Not listen to what you have clearly said over & over again?
Our society seems to have become allergic to listening.
We certainly seem to have a belief that we know all what is best for everyone else around us & that is our duty to let them know in no uncertain terms.
These comments smack of our society’s yearning to always ‘do’ more, ‘have’ more…….and not to just stop & consider that what we have is a blessing & something to treasure for what it is & nothing more.
You know I would totally be a bazillionaire if I could cash in on the crap comments that come my way about our 5 boys…
Some of the least hilarious (but most popular) of them are “Have you worked out what is causing it yet?”, “Trying for the girl eh?”, “Gee the power goes out at your place a lot”………
You know what……I LOVE that your gorgeous Benedict is exactly enough.
I LOVE that he is growing up in a house where he was soooooooo wanted.
I LOVE that you know yourself so well that you have conviction to live with your truth.
He is a lucky lucky boy.
xxxx
Stella Orbit
Mar 15, 2012 @ 20:50:00
That you had to endure even one round of any of those comments is sad.
You are totally right, so often it is the case that we think we need to let everyone know. We don’t.
Love to you and every one of your lovely boys xo
Kerri Sackville
Mar 15, 2012 @ 13:34:22
What a gorgeous post. I have several friends who have one child each, and they are all very happy with their one perfect angel. Ecstatically happy, actually. There are pros and cons to everything, and I think the chance to really enjoy one child without the utter chaos of two or three or more would be a wonderful thing. If it’s any consolation, I still get asked if I’m going to have more after 3 kids. My response? ‘I’ve been fixed’. You’d think that would shut them up but NO! ‘Well, you never know…’
YES I DO!!!!!!
Stella Orbit
Mar 15, 2012 @ 20:48:04
Indeed you do know. I’m using that from now. ‘Fixed’.
Still going to make the shirt though.
xo
pt
Mar 15, 2012 @ 09:50:01
Amen lady! I feel exactly the same way! I took to answering those questions and looks with “Nope I don’t need to I got one I liked first go!” Now that TC is in High School I have the answer “No thanks I don’t want one in nappies while the other is in a nightclub!” ;D xxpt
Stella Orbit
Mar 15, 2012 @ 20:46:46
Both excellent responses which I will press into service straight away!
Thanks xo
Michelle
Mar 15, 2012 @ 09:35:55
It is quite funny because I got the same rudeness but in reverse. When pregnant with number 4 there were more “are you mad?” than the simple and polite “congratulations”. Of course, entirely likely that I am mad but …
I so agree. None of anybody else’s business. And I love your conviction – I think it is hardest for people who feel conflicted or partners don’t agree about 1 or 2 or 3 or even none.
Benedict is blessed and so are you. With your beautiful one.
Michelle xx
Stella Orbit
Mar 15, 2012 @ 20:45:52
You are certainly not mad. Not at all.
Luckily there is no real conflict between the two of us about whether to have any more.
Polite congratulations should be the mandatory response to any pregnant woman.
Thank you xo
bigwords
Mar 15, 2012 @ 07:49:28
I’m a single child and now I have three girls. And you know what, people still ask us when we will be trying for a boy. All. The.Time. pisses me off.
You have a gorgeous child. What you do with your body is your own decision. xx
Stella Orbit
Mar 15, 2012 @ 20:42:44
That would be maddening.
I guess it is not over yet!
Thanks for your kind words. xo
Cat
Mar 14, 2012 @ 22:24:35
This is such a beautiful piece Louise. I detest how people make such assumptions and how they feel the right to ask such personal questions. I really, really agonised about having our second. In all our chatting I have assumed you’d only have one and I think he’s a lucky boy indeed to have you. I don’t know why a one-ly is so hard for others to accept. And if you make those tshirts I think you’d make a killing!
Stella Orbit
Mar 15, 2012 @ 20:42:00
It is the assumption that is really at the heart of the matter. We don’t assume it is ok to talk about other personal decisions with people unless we know and trust them and they give us permission. But when it is pregnancy and babies these rules don’t apply.
Thanks for your lovely comment xo